In numbers 14 it appears that moses changed the mind of. When moses heard this, he pleaded with god to turn from his anger. How the worlds most notorious atheist changed his mind was published by harperone. This is the question brother andrew explores in this thoughtprovoking look at a different kind of prayer. Perhaps it is simply enough to see varying commandments as evidence that god works with human beings in. Sep 24, 20 thats not a literal question but in the musical the book of mormon, when elder price is singing i believe, he says, i believe that in 1978 god changed his mind about black people. After seeing the first vision, about locusts, amos cried out, o lord god, please forgive. Because god has never had to change his mind from the foundation of the world ephesians 1. Logically, god, being god, cannot contradict himself or change his mind.
The bottom line is that god is entirely consistent. There is also the possibility that the word translated repent has more the idea of being grieved or sorry. Using illustrations from scripture and from his own. Although flew grew up as the son of a preacher, the problem of evil and flews academic studies led him to disbelieve in gods existence. Professor flew, who died in april 2010, has been called the worlds most influential philosophical atheist, as well as one of the most renowned atheists of the 20th century see peter. By charles fisher when i first heard the teaching that god lived in time, and changed his mind, i objected, on the grounds that god never changes, that the doctrine of immutability would not allow.
Thats not a literal question but in the musical the book of mormon, when elder price is singing i believe, he says, i believe that in 1978 god changed his mind about black people. Oct 21, 2018 through the bible with les feldick lesson 2 part 2 book 25 god has not changed his mind. The hebrew word typically translated change his mind or repent is nacham. He hated the people of nineveh for many logical and understandable reasons.
I seem to remember reading somewhere in the bible that he can change his mind. From the man who was responsible for millions of bibles smuggled behind the iron curtain, he tells his secret strategy. As a result, god, in his holiness, had mercy on nineveh and spared them. The latter two translations, as already explained, can mislead the reader into thinking that god really does not know what he is going to do, that he initially decides on one course of action, but in the end takes another course. What in moses words and actions would possibly have provoked god to change his mind. How the worlds most notorious atheist changed his mind reprint by antony flew, roy abraham varghese isbn. The threatened judgment didnt fall, and that nearly drove jonah crazy. While never embracing christianityflew only believed in the deistic, aristotelian conception of godhe became one of the most highprofile and surprising atheist converts. Things change, and they change according to his sovereign will, which he exercises through secondary means and secondary activities. By charles fisher when i first heard the teaching that god lived in time, and changed his mind, i objected, on the grounds that god never changes, that the doctrine of. Does he have more attributes, fewer attributes, better or worse attributes. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders.
God did not change what he had planned to do the same is true in the case of jonah and nineveh. Andrew, brother susan devore williams can prayer really change god s mind. Following the tragic death of a dear friend, i often felt speechless when i tried to prayas though my heart and mind had shut down. Theres one sense in which it seems god is changing his mind, and theres another sense in which the bible says god never changes his mind because god is omniscient. The people of nineveh prayed to god and asked his forgiveness.
In fact, god states very explicitly, i, the lord, do not change malachi 3. If gods plan is unalterable and he is immutable, in what sense can it be said that he changed his mind. First of all, it is apparent that moses disobeyed gods instruction to leave him alone v. God never goes back on his promises or tells us something one day and something different the next. No, god does not change his mind and i am glad for he probably would have changed his mind about saving me. This atheist says he is an atheist because he believes if god is real then he is either evil or impotent.
Reliable information about the coronavirus covid19 is available from the world health organization current situation, international travel. How the worlds most notorious atheist changed his mind flew, antony, varghese, roy abraham on. He refers to scriptures in proving that christians and jews may indeed justify asking god to change his mind. Andrew, brother susan devore williams can prayer really change gods mind. Lets start where we left off in romans chapter 11 verse 25.
Jan 02, 2020 the bottom line is that god is entirely consistent. Perhaps it is simply enough to see varying commandments as evidence that god works with human beings in an ongoing process of revelation. Oct 20, 2015 through the bible with les feldick lesson 2 part 2 book 25 god has not changed his mind lets start where we left off in romans chapter 11 verse 25. If god changed his mind, in that he adapted to new information, then god does not know all things 1 john 3. God has not changed his mind les feldick bible study.
God had changed his mind and told the angel to tell paul, god has granted you all those who sail with you acts 27. Every time god changed his mind it was in favor of humanity rather than against. What constitutes god as different in the second mode of being from what he was in the first. Numerous and frequentlyupdated resource results are available from this search. Applying this to the book of amos, there was nothing. It doesnt just happen in the ministry of jesus or in the new testament, the bible is a book about an mystifying god who shifts directions when you least expect it. Since we know this, we know that god does not actually change his mind, or regret his own actions, etc. Oclcs webjunction has pulled together information and resources to assist library staff as they consider how to handle coronavirus. His purpose to bless them is not based on their faithfulness, but on his unconditional love and grace. Who knows, god may turn and relent and withdraw his burning anger so that we will not perish. From humanitys point of view gods mind was changed but god had known all along what would happen.
If this is the correct translation then there is no issue here with respect to gods dealings with humanity. But this worries me, because he might change his mind about letting me into heaven. I believe that in 1978 god changed his mind about black people, sings elder kevin price in the broadway musical the book of mormon. Many would say that since god knows all things, he does not change his mind.
It is not in an eternal sense that he changes anything. The earnest prayer of a righteous person has great power and produces wonderful results. The explanation is that god knew in advance that he would offer mercy following the prayer of. He doesnt have any more information than he had a moment before. Relent, this article proposes, is a better choice than god changed his mind, or god repented overwas sorry about. Jun 14, 20 then after moses has actually said it, does god suddenly changes his mind. That is difficult to say, considering that gods foreknowledge allows him to anticipate events before they unfold. Apr 05, 2019 does this mean that god actually changes his mind. First of all, it is apparent that moses disobeyed god s instruction to leave him alone v. In 2007, he recounted his conversion in a book titled there is a god. Moses prayed for mercy and god answered his prayer.
And there are times in which god waits for us to ask for things because his plan is that we work with him in the glorious process of bringing his. Because the people of nineveh changed their minds about the way they had been living, and god changed his mind about destroying them. Once king saul of israel became firmly set in badness, god did not change his mind about rejecting him as king. Professor antony flew and coauthor abraham varghese have written a book, there is a god, describing flews conversion from atheism to deism. For one must then specify in what sense he has changed. This question can be best answered by breaking it into two questions.
Yet the bible frequently speaks of gods mercy in terms of god relenting from threatened judgment. Declaring the end from the beginning, and from ancient times things that are not yet done, saying, my counsel shall stand, and i will do all my pleasure. So how are we to understand the verses that claim that god changes his mind. Bestselling author eugene peterson changes his mind on gay. Im not convinced that it was the lord who changed his mind. The question was brought up in a quorum meeting,does god change his mind. This change of mind is entirely consistent with his character. From humanitys point of view god s mind was changed but god had known all along what would happen. Aug 24, 2016 not only do open theists argue that god changes his mind, but they also argue that he does not have exhaustive foreknowledge of future events. I dont think its like racist or anything, im genuinely curious about that history behind it. Then he gives examples of when he did just that, and god did change his mind.
Written by brother andrew of open doors and author of gods smuggler with susan williams, it speaks forcefully to the power and necessity of prayer in accomplishing gods will and participating in the kingdom of god. However, we do see verses in the bible that imply he does in a temporal sense. Verse 14 states, so the lord relented from the harm which he said he would do to his people. Through the bible with les feldick lesson 2 part 2 book 25 god has not changed his mind. Buy a cheap copy of and god changed his mind book by susan devore williams. It also means relented, and it does not mean that god changed his mind but that he embarked on another course of action. Bestselling author eugene peterson changes his mind on. And god changed his mind book by susan devore williams. God is immutable in his essence, attributes, and counsels or plans. When we read in the word of god that he was sorry, or that he relented or changed his mind, we must accept that it is expressing truth we could never begin to grasp were it not couched in the kind of language we commonly use of human emotions and actions. Instead of moses listening to god, he pleads with god to spare israel and god relents. On 1st november 2007, professor antony flews book there is a god. We can apply this verse to us also, for every promise god has made to us will be fulfilled. So how can prayer change circumstances without changing gods mind.
But if the bible is anything to go by, god can change his mind six times before breakfast and regularly does. One instance that was mentioned was josephs continual petition to the lord in the behalf of martin harris to show the manuscript to his wife. When god declared, for i am the lord, i do not change as recorded in malachi, he was talking about his nature. Consider some situations where the bible says that god has not changed his mind. One of his greatest promises to us is found in titus 1. The robust, thoughtful answers provided in this book offer a. Opinion racism and the mormon church the new york times. Bestselling author eugene peterson changes his mind on gay marriage. Another intelligent atheist changes his mind youtube. Mar 05, 20 1067 i believe from the book of mormon musical.
God told moses that the people deserved to be destroyed. The mind of god does not change for god does not change. There are two places in scripture where it says that god repented about something he had done in the past and almost a dozen times where it says that he changed his mind about something that he was about to do. When god instructed moses to go down to them, he told moses that he would consume them and make a great nation from moses 32. God did not allow balak to make him change his mind and curse the nation of israel.
Not only do open theists argue that god changes his mind, but they also argue that he does not have exhaustive foreknowledge of future events. God is eternal in his perspective and in his full knowledge of everything. I believe from the book of mormon musical on the 65th tony awards. May 21, 2015 his purpose to bless them is not based on their faithfulness, but on his unconditional love and grace.
How the worlds most notorious atheist changed his mind paperback november 4, 2008 by antony flew author. The book i was taught while suffering through catholic school must have miraculously changed at some point since those lessons. Nothing has changed as far as gods knowledge or his appraisal of the situation. Many statements in amos could be identified as major points within the minor prophets, but we will focus on one that should get the attention of any thoughtful reader. So the lord changed his mind about the harm which he said he would do to his people. Boyce states, by the immutability of god is meant that he is incapable of change, either in duration of life, or in nature, character, will or happiness.
In numbers 14 it appears that moses changed the mind of god. How the worlds most notorious atheist changed his mind by rich deem introduction. How the worlds most notorious atheist changed his mind. Sinai, and was influenced by moses who disobeyed gods command to leave him alone. However, this does not mean that god never changes his mind jer. Using illustrations from scripture as well as deep insight and practical advice gleaned from his own ministry, brother andrew shows that prayer can and does. People changing their minds god, repentance of mind, of god reformation obedience to god now therefore amend your ways and your deeds and obey the voice of the lord your god. God does change his mind in response to our obedience or rebellion, as mentioned in jeremiah.
74 1334 194 1169 1107 1574 82 1466 1242 1683 1147 571 729 795 209 1007 633 361 364 403 1042 1110 640 827 1536 1632 687 800 608 11 856 179 11 1071 33 617 2 321 1106 1191